Okay, having heard about Watchmen since it came out as a comic and having read the graphic novel, and currently re-reading it I can't really stay silent on the movie. I just read an article
[link] that didn't really say anything in their critique. So let me say something as someone that has an idea.
First let me say a few things about some changes that have happened since this comic was made. If this movie had been rated when I was a kid, it might have gotten a R or a PG-13 to which I would have been bombarded with adds for it in everything I watch having been an underage male at the time and still have gone to seen it. I know a lot has changed in rating movies since then. (Heck, Top Gun originally had a PG rating.) But let me get something out that I haven't found anyone talking about, and that is the audience for this comic/movie. Obviously this movie is made for the fans. Also, the movie is a good translation for the comic. However the audience that it's intended for won't be able to see it without their parents or parents permission until it comes out on DVD and BR. Heck how can we even know how good of a translation was made until we see this movie in these formats because they won't even release the long version to art house theaters? Anyway, the story was intended for young minds. It was made to make them think hard about the heroes they read about.
These stories were originally made to make people think about what a hero really is. If that is the sole purpose of the movie, then it seems to be doing what Watchmen does best. Especially if I look at all of the scuttlebutt. But what it comes down to is that Watchmen is a mature movie for young people, just like the comic. But our society is holding back on letting them get a hold of it because, being rated R it's too dangerous for them to buy until they can get the money for it themselves. (Amazing how commercialism walks around some people's restrictions)
Let me say also growing up I dealt with all kinds of stuff on screen that you just don't get in theaters for younger audiences anymore. Violence was considered so much a norm of movies. (For example Punisher: War Zone would have been a typical R movie of the era and just about any teenage kid would've seen it.) Sex was also a normal part of the movies. Films did reflect that and for it they got criticized and berated and now have a noose around their neck in the form of the MPAA current rating system. After all we all know that the MPAA is completely unbiased. (For those who think otherwise, please see "This Film is Not Yet Rated" if you haven't already.) The point is that whenever I see someone bring up violence or sex in a movie as being excessive, I see it as they can't think of anything else they can comment on because they're such stinking prudes.
So for those that say the sex and violence is too much in these movies, I say to get their head out of their tails and take a look at the world. I say this movie is more honest and more reflective than so many we've seen in years. I say this movie is beautiful and truly a masterpiece of film making. It's a good thing that so many people are picking sides with this movie because if ever there was a story that told us to pick sides, this was it. I'd say this is the Brokeback Mountains of the superhero movies in the sense that it breaks down the way people see superheros and puts them in another light.
Now is this movie a commercial success? Only time will tell, but nationally so far it's made about $87,000,000 out of a budget that is $120,000,000. Now add about $27,000,000 from the UK and it's not doing too bad for a March release. Is it going to be a block buster? Doubtfull, because so many people want to see the extended cut so they can make a final decision. Also, DVD/BR sales and rentals are a far way off. So, what will happen is up in the air.
If you did like the books, then you'll enjoy this movie. If you loved the books, then you won't be satisfied and probably won't until you see the directors cut. If you're someone that wants more meat and potatoes with your superhero movies, then this is the movie for you, because this movie asks, "What would I be like as a superhero?" and answers it with an honest and disturbing answer. If you love the kind of stories you had as a teenager in the eighties, this movie is for you. However, if you think that superheroes are bull and for children, you don't know how we need them so we can believe that we can be better and the lengths that some will go to do so, and this movie is not for you. If you're a stone-age bible thumper then you don't need to be seeing this movie because you can't take what's going on in the world around you and why the heck are you even reading anything I write. Remember also that this book is a beautiful work of subversive literature like, "The Adventures of Huck Finn." This is a story that says, "Don't accept what's out there," and demands "Question those in charge!" So in that sense, then Watchmen is a really fine adaptation of the story. Truly, typical of a truly good Moore story.